all guides

Campaigns, offers and sequences

What to send, to whom, and when to stop. Pick a campaign, set its offer, read its sequence message by message, check it against the contact rules, and write down the stop rule before the first send. Everything here is a method you run yourself: you press send.

free library

make it yours

showing an example product, shipnote. paste your site and we fill it in, or type yours once, and every template, search and message across the libraries switches to it.

the free autofills on this connection are used up for this hour

a shared connection counts as one, so this can happen on your first try. it resets within the hour, or join the waitlist and get 5 more today.

one email when vibedraft opens, and a short build note now and then. one click to leave.

Get the vibedraft newsletter, launch updates, and a chance to become a beta tester. Unsubscribe any time.

  1. opportunitywho to reach
  2. playthe strategy
  3. next movesthe steps
  4. campaignone run of them
  5. funnelwhat it produced
  • One play per campaignTwo plays on the same people at once means you can't tell which one worked.
  • Window and stop rule set firstDecide when it ends and what failure looks like before the first message goes out.
  • A holdout whenever you canA slice of the segment that gets nothing is the only way to know what the campaign caused.
templatePlayAlso called a playbook. When this moment shows up, use this channel and this offer, and stop at this result.reused: across products and monthsexample: Community answers
templateNext movesAlso called a sequence or cadence. The steps in order: wait, channel, action, message, who sends it, exit rule.reused: across playsexample: reply, follow-up, DM on request
instanceCampaignOne play and its next moves, on one segment, from a start date to a stop rule, split into arms.reused: never; presets are reusedexample: Reddit pain-reply sprint, Oct 20 to Nov 3
PlayNext movesCampaign
What it answersPlaywhat to do when this moment shows upNext moveswhich steps, in what orderCampaignwho, when, with which offer, and did it work
Has a datePlaynoNext movesnoCampaignyes: a start, a window and a readout date
Has people in itPlaynoNext movesnoCampaignyes: a segment, split into arms
Produces resultsPlayonly through campaignsNext movesonly through campaignsCampaignyes: counts per step, per arm

Build a campaign.

Pick a preset and it fills a campaign card: who, what they get, how long, when to stop, how it is split, and the day you read the result. Anything missing is flagged, because a campaign with no stop rule or no readout date runs until you forget it.

1 · the campaign

1. what are you after

2. pick a preset (14)

WaitlistListen and reply

Lead to waitlist

playbook: Lead to waitlist

readout dateset a start dateno start date means no day to read it.
The preset runs six weeks, or until you open.
0 to 90. Leave a slice out so you can see what it caused.
Versions to test
segment
people who showed a real need for what you are building and that you have not contacted yet
offer
a free write-up of their own situation, with a waitlist sign-up on it
stop rule
40 offers made and 0 joins: change the offer, not the queue
goal metric
waitlist joins per offer
win rule
waitlist joins per offer at least double the holdout's, with enough people in each arm to tell
holdout
10% get nothing, picked at random
arms
treatment 90%holdout 10%
steps
  1. a helpful public reply
  2. a light touch
  3. one private message with the write-up and the waitlist
  4. one nudge
open this sequence, step by step

The whole chain on one page: find the person, answer in public, make one private offer.

  • 1 thing missing. A campaign with no stop rule or no readout date runs until you forget it, and you learn nothing from it.
  • No start date, so there is no readout date.
edit the words (use {slot} for anything from make it yours)
A count, not a feeling: 40 offers made and 0 joins.
Written before you see numbers.

3. can your list tell? holdout and sample size

Small lists read big effects only. Test changes big enough to double a rate, and write the number down before you start. Sized against your arms: treatment 90%, holdout 10%.

How many you could reach in the window.
Of those who get the offer, how many say yes now.
Doubling is a fair bet to size for.
No numbers yet?

Fill the three numbers to see whether your list can fill these arms.

worked examples (not your data)

Rate today to hopedPer arm, rulePer arm, exactReads as
10% to 20%Per arm, rule204Per arm, exact199Reads asa big effect, findable with a few hundred leads
5% to 10%Per arm, rule444Per arm, exact435Reads asneeds a month or more of leads
10% to 13%Per arm, rule1,810Per arm, exact1,774Reads asout of reach for one founder; pool campaigns or accept a direction
2% to 4%Per arm, rule1,164Per arm, exact1,141Reads astypical cold reply rates are this low; test big changes only

Windows, stop rules and holdout shares are starting points to adjust, not benchmarks. Nothing here sends anything: the presets are a plan, and you send every message yourself.

Segments and arms.

A segment is the rule that decides who a campaign runs on, written once and frozen into a list on the day it starts. Arms are the versions that run side by side; the holdout is the arm that gets nothing.

2 · who, and who gets what
  1. 1 · hard excludesNever, customers, competitorsYour never-contact list, customers' staff and competitors, then the not-if lines of who you sell to.
  2. 2 · contact policyAlready busyAnyone in another live campaign, past their message cap, or who asked to stop.
  3. 3 · rule matchThe segment ruleTier, trigger, signal age, source, fit lines, engagement history.
  4. 4 · freezeSnapshotWrite the member list down with the date. Someone who qualifies tomorrow joins the next campaign, not this one.

14 of 14

Cold

Hot leads with fresh public pain

People who posted the exact pain in the last 48 hours and pass every fit line.

rule
tier in (Hot) and trigger = public_pain and signal_age_h <= 48 and contacted = false
used by
Reddit pain-reply sprint, Lead to waitlist
size
small; refresh daily
Cold

Warm leads nobody has contacted

Fit and a real signal, but weaker or older. The bulk of most queues.

rule
tier in (Hot, Warm) and contacted = false and not in never_list
used by
Lead to waitlist
size
the largest cold segment
Cold

Unhappy with a competitor, this week

Complained publicly about a named competitor in the last 7 days.

rule
trigger = competitor_complaint and signal_age_h <= 168 and icp_fit = true
used by
Competitor-unhappy switch offer
size
depends on how loud the category is
Cold

1 to 3 star reviewers, last 30 days

Reviewers of a competitor on G2, Capterra or the app stores who can be found publicly.

rule
source in (g2, capterra, app_store) and rating <= 3 and signal_age_h <= 720 and identity_found = true
used by
Review-site responders
size
small; found by hand
Cold

"Alternative to" askers

People asking for an alternative to, or a comparison with, a named competitor.

rule
trigger in (asks_alternative, comparison_question) and signal_age_h <= 72
used by
Comparison-page interception
size
steady trickle
Cold

Founders in launch week

Launched on Show HN, Product Hunt or a directory in the last 7 days, in your ICP.

rule
trigger = launched and signal_age_h <= 168 and icp_fit = true
used by
Launch-week offers, Founder swap
size
weekly batches
Cold

Lurkers who engaged twice

Liked, replied or bookmarked your posts at least twice in 30 days but never talked to you.

rule
engagements_30d >= 2 and contacted = false
used by
Waitlist countdown follow-ups
size
grows with your posting
Warm

Keyword commenters

Everyone who commented the keyword on an offer post. They asked; the clock is short.

rule
trigger = hand_raise and post_id = {offer_post} and signal_age_h <= 24
used by
Comment-a-keyword lead magnet
size
whatever the post earns
Warm

Waitlist joiners who have not come back

Joined the waitlist and never opened the follow-up or answered its question.

rule
waitlist = true and days_since_join >= 3 and replied = false
used by
Waitlist countdown, beta recruit
size
grows with the waitlist
Warm

Stalled trials, day 3

Started a trial and have not done the key action by day 3.

rule
trial_day >= 3 and key_action_done = false and plan = trial
used by
Stalled-trial rescue
size
after launch only
Customers

Failed payments

Every customer with a failed invoice. Never held out: the money is owed.

rule
payment_event = invoice.payment_failed and resolved = false
used by
Failed payment recovery
size
always on
Customers

Cancelled 30 to 90 days ago

Past customers far enough out to have cooled down, close enough to remember you.

rule
payment_event = subscription.deleted and days_since in [30, 90] and never_list = false
used by
Win-back
size
small
Customers

Former paying customers (relaunch)

People who paid for an earlier version. The warmest list a relaunching product has.

rule
ever_paid = true and plan = none
used by
Relaunch announcement, early access
size
usually small, and worth the most per person
Partners

Partner founders

Founders who sell to the same buyers with a product that does not compete, close to your size.

rule
kind = founder and audience_overlap = high and competes = false and size_ratio in [0.5, 2]
used by
Founder swap
size
a short list, built by hand
write any segment in one line: the rule grammar
rule     := clause ( ("and" | "or") clause )*
clause   := field op value  |  "not" clause
op       := "=" | "!=" | "in" | "<" | "<=" | ">" | ">=" | "within"

fields   tier, trigger, signal_age_h, source, icp_fit, contacted,
         last_touch_days, in_campaign, never_list, engagements_30d,
         waitlist, days_since_join, trial_day, key_action_done,
         plan, ever_paid, payment_event, rating, reply_class

Keep rules this small so a segment can be written down, dated and shown to you in one line. Exclusions run first, so nothing you matched can bring a never-contact person back in.

The offer ladder.

The offer is what a person gets for saying yes, and the single biggest lever in a campaign. Each yes earns the next, bigger ask. Jumping rungs is the most common reason a campaign gets replies but no joins.

3 · what they get
  • Give before you askCold people get something useful first. The waitlist or the price comes after.
  • Match the ask to the warmthA stranger can say yes to opening a link, not to a call. A trial user can say yes to a call.
  • Change the offer before the queueWhen a campaign stalls, the offer is the first thing to swap, not the people.

1. where are you, and who is it

Your stage
How warm are they

a stranger showing a signal.

2. the ladder: each yes earns the next, bigger ask

Tap a rung to see the offers that live on it. Teal rungs are the ones your stage points to.

3. the right rung for them

Start on rung 1 (Give) and work toward rung 3 (Small ask). A stranger can say yes to opening a link, not to a call. Earn the waitlist ask with an answer and a write-up first.

  1. 1A useful answer, nothing asked rung 1
  2. 2A free write-up of their own product rung 2
  3. 3A waitlist spot rung 3
  • A useful answer, nothing askedAnswer the question in the thread. The product is named only if they ask.ask: none. cost: 10 to 20 minutes.says: "none; your profile does the work"
  • A free write-up of their own productYou read their site and hand back a short brief: who buys, what hurts, where they hang out.ask: open a link. cost: about 15 minutes by hand.says: "here's what I found for {their product}"
  • A waitlist spotGet in line for early access. The smallest ask a pre-launch product has.ask: leave an email. cost: none.says: "join the waitlist"

4. don't jump rungs: check one offer

Jumping rungs. That skips 2 rungs. Put a smaller offer first: they have not said yes to anything near this yet.

stage by warmth: the path to use

Your stageColdWarmCustomer
Not open yetColda useful answer, nothing asked, then a free write-up of their own product, then a waitlist spotWarmearly access, then a founding priceCustomerearly access
Launched, no one payingColda useful answer, nothing asked, then a free tool, then a free trialWarma setup call, then first month freeCustomernot applicable
Signups, no paymentsColda free tool, then a free trialWarma setup call, then done-for-you setupCustomera link to update the card, then a setup call
A few customersColdan honest comparison page, then a free trialWarma founding price, then free migration from a competitorCustomerhalf price to come back, then a referral ask

all 15 offers

15 of 15

Give

A useful answer, nothing asked

Answer the question in the thread. The product is named only if they ask.

ask
none
cost
10 to 20 minutes
fits
cold, public pain, any stage
says
none; your profile does the work
Give

A free write-up of their own product

You read their site and hand back a short brief: who buys, what hurts, where they hang out.

ask
open a link
cost
about 15 minutes by hand
fits
founders, pre-launch, cold or warm
says
here's what I found for {their product}
Give

Three leads for their product

A lead magnet: real people asking for what they built, delivered by message.

ask
comment a keyword
cost
your time per delivery
fits
comment-a-keyword posts
says
comment the word
Give

A playbook pack

The written playbooks for their stage, filled with their product.

ask
comment or reply
cost
near zero once written
fits
audience building, hand-raises
says
comment the word
Give

A free tool

A calculator, checker or generator that answers one question for free.

ask
use it
cost
build time, once
fits
search and AI answers, always on
says
try it
Small ask

A waitlist spot

Get in line for early access. The smallest ask a pre-launch product has.

ask
leave an email
cost
none
fits
pre-launch, after value was given
says
join the waitlist
Small ask

Early access

In before everyone else, usually with a direct line to you.

ask
sign up
cost
support time
fits
pre-launch, beta
says
get early access
Small ask

Free beta, set up with them

Free access while it is in beta, and you set it up on a call.

ask
15 minutes
cost
your call time
fits
finding testers
says
reply to get set up
Big ask

A setup call

Fifteen minutes to get them to the key action.

ask
book a call
cost
your time
fits
stalled trials, warm leads asking how
says
pick a time
Big ask

Done-for-you setup

You do the setup for them.

ask
give access
cost
high time cost
fits
high-value trials only
says
want me to set it up?
Big ask

Free migration from a competitor

Move their data or setup over from the tool they are unhappy with.

ask
switch
cost
your time
fits
competitor-unhappy, reviewers
says
I'll move it for you
Price

A founding price

A lower price locked in for the first customers.

ask
pay
cost
revenue per customer
fits
launch, waitlist opening
says
lock in the founding price
Price

First month free

Removes the price for a month; the card still goes in.

ask
start a trial with a card
cost
one month of revenue
fits
switchers, launch week
says
start free
Price

Half price to come back

What changed since they left, and a month at half price.

ask
resubscribe
cost
half a month
fits
cancelled 30 to 90 days ago
says
come back for half
Price

A link to update the card

Nothing else. They already decided to pay.

ask
update card
cost
none
fits
failed payments only
says
update your card

what goes wrong with offers

What goes wrongHow it shows upHow to catch it
Asking too earlyHow it shows upReplies, but nobody takes the askHow to catch itCheck which rung the ask sits on; insert a give step before it
Value not delivered fastHow it shows upPeople said yes, then went quietHow to catch itKeep the time from yes to delivery under 24 hours
Discount habitHow it shows upEvery campaign needs a price cut to workHow to catch itTest value offers (a write-up, a setup) against price offers
Offer does not match the triggerHow it shows upA migration offer to someone who just launchedHow to catch itWrite down where each offer is allowed, and refuse mismatches at setup

Stop rules and readouts.

Every campaign ends one of three ways: its window runs out, a stop rule fires, or you stop it. Whichever way, it ends in a readout on a date you set at launch. Losses are half the learnings, so write the row even when it failed.

4 · when it ends
Every stop rule has a minimum sample."0 joins" means nothing after 3 offers. Write the count into the rule, set the readout date before you send, and judge the goal once, on the day. Guardrails are the exception: those you watch the whole time.

does your stop rule have a minimum sample

Try "0 joins" to see why a rule with no count is not a rule.

three clocks run at once

CheckHow oftenWhat it can do
Guardrails (stop requests, removals, account status)How oftenevery time one happensWhat it can dopause the campaign immediately
Futility rulesHow oftenonce a day, after the minimum sampleWhat it can dostop early and write down why
Budgets (minutes, spend)How oftenweeklyWhat it can dopause or shrink the segment
Goal metric against the win ruleHow oftenonce, on the readout dateWhat it can dodecide: repeat, change one thing, retire

twelve stop rules

12 of 12

Futility

Futility by count

Enough tries with nothing to show for it.

rule
offers_made >= 40 and joins = 0
checked
daily
then
change the offer, not the queue
Futility

Futility by rate

A rate stays under a floor after a minimum sample.

rule
touches >= 50 and reply_rate < 0.02
checked
daily after the minimum sample
then
change the segment or the opener
Futility

Engagement floor

Public plays that draw no attention.

rule
answers >= 20 and profile_visits < 2
checked
daily
then
wrong communities: swap them
Guardrail

Stop requests

People asking you to stop is the first guardrail.

rule
stop_requests per 100 touches >= 2
checked
every time one arrives
then
pause, read the replies, fix the sequence
Guardrail

Removals and reports

Comments removed or accounts reported on a platform.

rule
removed_or_reported >= 1 in a community
checked
every time one arrives
then
stop in that community; re-read its rules
Guardrail

Your time budget

The campaign is eating the week.

rule
minutes_this_week > budget
checked
weekly
then
cut steps or the segment
Guardrail

Spend budget

Tools, credits or ads cost more than planned.

rule
spend > budget
checked
weekly
then
pause; check cost per join
Time

Window end

The default: the campaign ends on its end date.

rule
today > window.end
checked
daily
then
read it out on the readout date
Time

Segment exhausted

Everyone in the frozen list has finished the sequence.

rule
members_active = 0
checked
daily
then
read out early, once late replies have had time to land
Success

Early win, written at launch only

Stopping early for success is allowed only with a rule set at launch and a minimum sample.

rule
per_arm_n >= 150 and lift > 2x and holdout_n >= 30
checked
weekly
then
ship the winner; log it as an early stop
External

Platform or account trouble

A ban, a rate-limit wall, or an account that needs reconnecting.

rule
account.status != active
checked
every time you send
then
pause; nothing sends from a broken account
External

Stopped by hand

You end it. Allowed, but the reason is required.

rule
your call
checked
any time
then
write down the reason; still write the readout

the row every finished campaign leaves behind

FieldWhat it recordsExample
Who and whenWhat it recordscampaign name, playbook and sequence, datesExampleReddit pain-reply sprint, community-answers, Oct 20 to Nov 3
ArmsWhat it recordseach arm's size and how people were assignedExampleanswer: 41 threads, holdout: 39 threads, random by thread
Funnel per armWhat it recordscounts at each rung of the ladderExamplefound, engaged, pain stated, offer made, joined
LiftWhat it recordsgoal metric per arm, the difference, and how sureExamplevisits per thread 0.32 vs 0.05; small sample, read as a direction
GuardrailsWhat it recordsstop requests, reports, removalsExample0 stop requests, 1 removed comment
CostWhat it recordsyour minutes and any spendExample6 hours, no spend
Stop reasonWhat it recordswindow ended, stop rule fired, or stopped by handExamplewindow ended
Decision and learningWhat it recordsrepeat, change one thing, or retire, plus one sentence for next timeExamplerepeat, swap two communities: answers under 6 hours old drew almost every visit

The example numbers are invented to show the shape of a row.

Twelve sequences, message by message.

A sequence is a playbook's messages in order: which step goes out, on which day, who sends it, and what ends it. Open any step to read its message with your product filled in.

5 · the steps in order

12 of 12 sequences

you you send it by hand. scheduled you queue it ahead of time. system no message: a wait, a branch, a note to self. Every first message to a stranger is yours.

Listen and reply4 steps

Lead to waitlist

goal: waitlist join. starts with: a lead who fits and showed a real need, never contacted.

  1. day 0
    Public replyyou

    the one thing that fixes what they posted

    the message, with your words
    saw this. {their words} is rough, and i have been there with writing the changelog by hand every friday.
    
    the thing that moved it for me: {one concrete step}. took about {time}.
    
    the part i would skip: {common wrong move}.
  2. after they answer
    Light touchyou

    a short answer to what they asked back

    the message, with your words
    glad that helped. one more thing that matters at your stage: {detail tied to their numbers}.
  3. next
    Send their write-upyou

    their write-up, with the waitlist; once

    the message, with your words
    here is what i found for {their product}: who pays, what hurts, where they hang out. {tracked link}
    
    if it is useful, there is a waitlist for shipnote on the page. no worries if not.
  4. one nudge
    Follow-up DMyou

    did the write-up show anyone worth answering?

    the message, with your words
    did the write-up show you anyone worth answering? curious what you saw.

ends when: joined, asked to stop, out of steps

Listen and reply4 steps

Reddit pain reply to DM

goal: reply, then a DM. starts with: a pain post in a watched community, under 48 hours old.

  1. day 0
    Public replyyou

    answer the thread; offer the template only if asked

    the message, with your words
    saw this. {their words} is rough, and i have been there with writing the changelog by hand every friday.
    
    the thing that moved it for me: {one concrete step}. took about {time}.
    
    the part i would skip: {common wrong move}.
  2. on reply
    Branch on replysystem

    positive or question: DM. stop: exit

    how to run this step

    Pick the next step from how they answered: positive, question, not now, stop. No message goes out: this step is no message at all: a wait, a branch, a note to self.

  3. +1 day
    Direct messageyou

    the template or a 5-minute look, no pitch

    the message, with your words
    here is the template i mentioned: {the template or a link to it}. happy to look at yours for five minutes if you want.
  4. +4 days
    Follow-up DMyou

    one nudge, only if they engaged

    the message, with your words
    did {step you suggested} make a difference? curious what you saw.

ends when: replied, asked to stop, out of steps

Listen and reply3 steps

X pain reply

goal: profile visit, then a reply. starts with: an X post matching a pain phrase, under 24 hours old.

  1. day 0
    Public replyyou

    reply with one concrete step

    the message, with your words
    saw this. {their words} is rough.
    
    the thing that moved it for me: {one concrete step}. free to try.
  2. same day
    Quote postyou

    only if they are a builder others follow

    the message, with your words
    {one thing you add to their post, in your own words}. {their point} is the part most people miss.
  3. +2 days
    Light touchyou

    if they answered, answer back

    the message, with your words
    glad that helped. one more thing that matters at your stage: {detail tied to their numbers}.

ends when: replied, ignored, asked to stop

Your own channels3 steps

Comment a keyword

goal: hand-raise, then a signup. starts with: someone comments the keyword on your post.

  1. minutes
    Comment-a-keyword replyscheduled

    the resource they asked for, with a tracked link

    the message, with your words
    sent it. check your messages. {what you sent and one line on how to use it}
  2. +2 days
    Follow-up DMyou

    did it help? one line

    the message, with your words
    did it help? one line is plenty.
  3. on positive
    Add to waitlistsystem

    note the signup and which message earned it

    how to run this step

    Turns a yes into a waitlist row, with a note of which message earned it. No message goes out: this step is no message at all: a wait, a branch, a note to self.

ends when: joined, asked to stop

Your own channels4 steps

Waitlist countdown

goal: waitlist joins. starts with: your audience; no individual entry.

  1. day 1
    Own postscheduled

    say what is coming; link in the reply

    the message, with your words
    shipnote opens on {date}. it writes release notes from commits for solo founders who ship weekly.
    
    why i am building it: writing the changelog by hand every friday.
    
    i will post one pain a day until then.
  2. days 2 to 13
    Own postscheduled

    one pain per day

    the message, with your words
    pain #{n}: writing the changelog by hand every friday.
    
    {one line on how people deal with it today, and what is wrong with that}.
  3. on signup
    Emailscheduled

    confirm and ask one question

    the message, with your words
    subject: you are on the list
    
    thanks for joining the shipnote waitlist.
    
    one question: what is the first thing you would use it for? reply to this and i will read it.
  4. day 14
    Emailscheduled

    open the doors; email before posting

    the message, with your words
    subject: shipnote is open
    
    it writes release notes from commits for solo founders who ship weekly. $19 a month for the first people in.
    
    {link}

ends when: campaign window ends

Listen and reply4 steps

Beta invite

goal: active testers. starts with: replied to the call-out and fits who you build for.

  1. day 0
    Direct messageyou

    qualify: are you in this situation right now?

    the message, with your words
    saw your post about {their words}. i am looking for a few people to try shipnote free while it is in beta, and i will set it up with you. are you dealing with writing the changelog by hand every friday right now?
  2. on yes
    Task for youyou

    set it up with them, 15 minutes

    how to run this step

    Something only a person can do: find an email, record a video, check a profile, get on a call. No message goes out: this step is you send it by hand.

  3. +3 days
    Task for youyou

    feedback call: three questions

    how to run this step

    Something only a person can do: find an email, record a video, check a profile, get on a call. No message goes out: this step is you send it by hand.

  4. +10 days
    Direct messageyou

    ask to quote one line

    the message, with your words
    would you be ok with me quoting one line from what you said about it? i will show you the wording first.

ends when: used it twice, declined, asked to stop

Your own channels5 steps

Launch day

goal: launch-week signups. starts with: a launch scheduled on a directory.

  1. day -7
    Emailscheduled

    tell your list the date

    the message, with your words
    subject: shipnote launches on {date}
    
    the short version: shipnote writes release notes from commits. i would love your help on the day.
    
    i will email once more the day before.
  2. day 0
    Own postscheduled

    the launch post

    the message, with your words
    shipnote is live today.
    
    writes release notes from commits, for solo founders who ship weekly.
    
    the link is in the reply.
  3. day 0
    Task for youyou

    answer every comment within the hour

    how to run this step

    Something only a person can do: find an email, record a video, check a profile, get on a call. No message goes out: this step is you send it by hand.

  4. day 1
    Own postscheduled

    the results, with numbers

    the message, with your words
    day one of shipnote: {real number} signups, {real number} comments.
    
    what surprised me: {one thing}.
  5. day 7
    Own postscheduled

    the week after: who is still using it

    the message, with your words
    one week after launching shipnote: {real number} still using it.
    
    what i would do differently: {one thing}.

ends when: window ends

Listen and reply3 steps

Competitor review responder

goal: reply, then a trial. starts with: a 1 to 3 star review of a competitor, under 14 days old.

  1. day 0
    Public replyyou

    only where replies are allowed; answer the complaint, not the vendor

    the message, with your words
    that sounds frustrating. {their complaint in your words}: one thing that sometimes helps is {workaround}.
  2. on reply
    Branch on replysystem

    positive: offer. otherwise exit

    how to run this step

    Pick the next step from how they answered: positive, question, not now, stop. No message goes out: this step is no message at all: a wait, a branch, a note to self.

  3. +1 day
    Send their write-upyou

    what switching takes, in their words

    the message, with your words
    if you are still looking, here is what switching from beamer takes: {steps in their words}. i can help with it.

ends when: replied, ignored, asked to stop

Customer lifecycle4 steps

Warm list reactivation

goal: reply or a return visit. starts with: signed up or joined the waitlist 30+ days ago, inactive.

  1. day 0
    Emailscheduled

    what changed since they signed up, one line each

    the message, with your words
    subject: what changed in shipnote
    
    hi {first name}, you signed up a while back.
    
    since then: {change one}, {change two}.
    
    if you still have writing the changelog by hand every friday, it may be worth another look.
  2. +3 days
    Email follow-upscheduled

    one question: what were you hoping it would do?

    the message, with your words
    one question: what were you hoping shipnote would do for you? reply with a line and i will read it.
  3. on reply
    Branch on replysystem

    positive: task. not now: wait 30 days

    how to run this step

    Pick the next step from how they answered: positive, question, not now, stop. No message goes out: this step is no message at all: a wait, a branch, a note to self.

  4. on positive
    Task for youyou

    personal reply

    how to run this step

    Something only a person can do: find an email, record a video, check a profile, get on a call. No message goes out: this step is you send it by hand.

ends when: replied, unsubscribed, returned

Customer lifecycle4 steps

Stalled trial rescue

goal: activation. starts with: trial day 2 with no first key action.

  1. day 2
    Emailscheduled

    the one step that predicts paying, with a link straight to it

    the message, with your words
    subject: the one step that matters in shipnote
    
    hi {first name}, most people who stick with shipnote do one thing first: {key action}.
    
    the shortest way to it: {link to the step}.
  2. day 4
    Email follow-upscheduled

    offer to set it up for them

    the message, with your words
    want me to set it up with you? 15 minutes, and i will do the clicking.
  3. on reply
    Task for youyou

    do the setup together

    how to run this step

    Something only a person can do: find an email, record a video, check a profile, get on a call. No message goes out: this step is you send it by hand.

  4. day 6
    Stop / exitsystem

    stop before the trial ends

    how to run this step

    Ends the sequence for this person and says why. No message goes out: this step is no message at all: a wait, a branch, a note to self.

ends when: activated, converted, unsubscribed

Customer lifecycle3 steps

Failed payment recovery

goal: payment recovered. starts with: your payment processor reports a failed payment.

  1. hour 0
    Emailscheduled

    plain note: the card failed, here is the update link

    the message, with your words
    subject: your card did not go through
    
    hi {first name}, the payment for shipnote failed. it happens.
    
    update your card here: {billing link}
  2. +3 days
    Email follow-upscheduled

    second note, still friendly

    the message, with your words
    second note, no pressure: {billing link}. if something is wrong, reply and i will sort it.
  3. +6 days
    Task for youyou

    personal message if they are a long-time customer

    how to run this step

    Something only a person can do: find an email, record a video, check a profile, get on a call. No message goes out: this step is you send it by hand.

ends when: paid, cancelled

Customer lifecycle3 steps

Win-back

goal: resubscribe. starts with: cancelled 30 to 90 days ago.

  1. day 30
    Emailscheduled

    what changed since they left, tied to their cancel reason

    the message, with your words
    subject: what changed in shipnote
    
    hi {first name}, you cancelled a while back, so here is what is different now: {what changed, tied to why they left}.
    
    if it is useful, come back for half price for a month: {link}
  2. +7 days
    Email follow-upscheduled

    one question: what would bring you back?

    the message, with your words
    one question: what would bring you back? one line is plenty.
  3. on positive
    Offer a callyou

    only if they answered

    the message, with your words
    if it is easier to see it than read about it, i can set it up with you in 15 minutes. want a time?

ends when: resubscribed, unsubscribed, out of steps

what goes wrong with sequences

What goes wrongHow it shows upHow to catch it
Double sendHow it shows upThe same DM goes out twiceHow to catch itKeep one row per person per step; check it before you send
Exit not checkedHow it shows upA nudge after they already said noHow to catch itLook for a reply or a stop request right before each send
Wrong timezoneHow it shows upMessages arrive at 3am their timeHow to catch itSend inside their waking hours when you know their timezone, yours otherwise
Channel unavailableHow it shows upA DM step on an account with closed DMsHow to catch itBranch to a public step or a task

Seventeen step components.

Every sequence is built from the same few parts: messages, public posts, value you hand over, and control steps like a wait or a branch. Build a step once and reuse it, so a result always points at the exact step that earned it.

6 · the parts
  • A step is one actionOne message, one wait, one branch. Never two sends in one step.
  • Exit is checked before every sendIf they replied, asked to stop or converted, the next step never runs.
  • Every step has a way outA reply, a stop request, a signup or a bounce ends the sequence for that person.

17 of 17

Messageyou

Public reply

Answer in the thread where they posted. Visible to everyone, so it has to help on its own.

channel
Reddit thread, X reply, Threads reply
wait
day 0, within the trigger's freshness window
runs if
thread still open; not removed
exits on
they reply, the thread locks, a mod removes it
write down
thread url, what you sent, edits, removal
the starter message, with your words
saw this. {their words} is rough, and i have been there with writing the changelog by hand every friday.

the thing that moved it for me: {one concrete step}. took about {time}.

the part i would skip: {common wrong move}.
Messageyou

Light touch

A short second reply or reaction after they answer: thanks, a follow-up question.

channel
same thread
wait
after they answer
runs if
their reply was positive or a question
exits on
no answer in 3 days
write down
what they said, what you answered
the starter message, with your words
glad that helped. one more thing that matters at your stage: {detail tied to their numbers}.
Messageyou

Direct message

The one private message. Carries the offer, not a hello.

channel
X DM, Reddit chat (Threads has no DM API: that step is a task for you)
wait
after a public exchange, or on request
runs if
DMs are open; you have never sent them one
exits on
replied, asked to stop, out of steps
write down
the offer you made, the link, whether it landed
the starter message, with your words
saw your post about {their words}.

{offer}

{tracked link}

no worries if not.
Messageyou

Follow-up DM

One nudge if the DM got no answer.

channel
same as the DM
wait
+3 to 4 days, only if no reply
runs if
no reply to the DM; under the unanswered cap
exits on
reply, stop, cap reached
write down
days since the DM, any reply
the starter message, with your words
did {step you suggested} make a difference? curious what you saw.
Messagescheduled

Email

For people who gave you an address: waitlist, trial, customers. Never a scraped one.

channel
email
wait
day 0 for warm lists
runs if
they gave you the address; not unsubscribed
exits on
reply, unsubscribe, bounce
write down
subject, bounces, any reply
the starter message, with your words
subject: quick question about shipnote

hi {first name},

you joined for writing the changelog by hand every friday. what were you hoping shipnote would do first?

reply to this one. i read every answer.
Messagescheduled

Email follow-up

The second email, shorter, one ask. Two at most.

channel
email, same thread
wait
+2 to 4 days
runs if
no reply; not unsubscribed
exits on
reply, unsubscribe, conversion
write down
position in the thread, any reply
the starter message, with your words
bumping this once. if now is not the time, ignore it and i will not write again.
Messageyou

Comment-a-keyword reply

The reply to someone who commented your keyword: confirm, then deliver.

channel
the post's thread, then DM
wait
within hours of the comment
runs if
they commented the keyword
exits on
delivered, asked to stop
write down
delivery time
the starter message, with your words
sent it. check your messages, and tell me if it is not there so i can resend.
Publicyou

Quote post

Quote their public post with something useful, when replying would bury it.

channel
X, Threads
wait
day 0, the same day as their post
runs if
the post is public and recent; they are a builder others follow
exits on
n/a
write down
post id, how it did
the starter message, with your words
{one thing you add to their post, in your own words}. {their point} is the part most people miss.
Publicscheduled

Own post

A post on your account that the sequence depends on: the offer post, a launch post. The link goes in the first reply.

channel
X, Threads, Instagram, TikTok
wait
per sequence
runs if
n/a
exits on
n/a
write down
post id, numbers at 1 hour, 1 day, 7 days
the starter message, with your words
{n} people asked me some version of "{question}" this week.

short answer: {answer}.

the longer version is in the reply.
Valueyou

Send their write-up

Deliver the free write-up of their product: the value half of the offer.

channel
inside a DM or email
wait
with the DM
runs if
you have read their site and written it up
exits on
opened, ignored
write down
whether they opened it
the starter message, with your words
here is what i found for {their product}: who pays, what hurts, where they hang out. {tracked link}

if it is useful, {offer}. no worries if not.
Valuesystem

Add to waitlist

Turns a yes into a waitlist row, with a note of which message earned it.

channel
waitlist form or reply
wait
on yes
runs if
they said yes, or clicked the link
exits on
joined
write down
the first and last message before the signup
Valueyou

Offer a call

Fifteen minutes to set them up. A big ask: warm leads only, and only after two positive replies.

channel
DM or email
wait
after a positive reply
runs if
warm; on a trial or asked how
exits on
booked, declined, no answer
write down
booked or not, showed up or not
the starter message, with your words
if it is easier to see it than read about it, i can set it up with you in 15 minutes. want a time?
Valuesystem

Tracked link

A short link of your own whose clicks you can count. It rides inside a message, never alone.

channel
inside any message
wait
n/a
runs if
any step with a link
exits on
n/a
write down
which message carried it, clicks with time
Controlsystem

Wait

Do nothing for a while. A wait is a step too, so its length can be tested.

channel
none
wait
+N hours or days
runs if
always
exits on
n/a
write down
planned against actual send day
Controlsystem

Branch on reply

Pick the next step from how they answered: positive, question, not now, stop.

channel
none
wait
on reply
runs if
a reply arrived
exits on
n/a
write down
how you read the reply, and which branch you took
Controlyou

Task for you

Something only a person can do: find an email, record a video, check a profile, get on a call.

channel
none
wait
per sequence
runs if
n/a
exits on
done, skipped
write down
what you did, minutes, why you skipped
Controlsystem

Stop / exit

Ends the sequence for this person and says why.

channel
none
wait
any time
runs if
an exit condition is met
exits on
n/a
write down
exit reason: replied, stop, converted, bounced, out of steps

Templates and variants.

A template is the reusable shape of a message: fixed lines, slots for the facts, and the rules a draft has to pass. A slot with no source stays empty or the line is cut. A made-up fact is worse than a weaker message.

7 · the words

five hard rules for every message

  • No em dashesThey read as machine-written. Use a period, a comma or a colon.
  • No links in X post bodies; links go in a replyPosts without links reach further.
  • No invented events, numbers or quotesEverything factual comes from your notes, the post you are answering, or a real result you can show.
  • No reaction-bait closers ("agree?")They ask for engagement instead of earning it.
  • Lowercase voice, varied openersWrite the way you talk, and start each message differently.

the first private message, as a template

Fill in who it is for. Your product comes from make it yours above. Anything left in braces is for you to write: a message with a hole in it should never go out.

saw your post about {their words}. i read through {their site} and wrote up who pays for {their product} and where they hang out: {tracked link}

if it is useful, there is a waitlist for shipnote on the page. no worries if not.
  • Passes: Under 60 words

    43 words

  • Passes: One link only
  • Passes: No em dashes
  • Fails: No empty {slot} left in it

    {their words}, {their site}, {their product}, {tracked link}

43 words. Fix the failing rule before you send.

fourteen slots, and where each one comes from

14 of 14

Your product

The buyer

Who the product is for, as they would describe themselves.

slot
{who}
from
make it yours: who it is for
fallback
leave the placeholder; do not guess
Your product

The pain it removes

The annoying thing they do today.

slot
{pain}
from
make it yours: the pain
fallback
use their words from the post instead
Your product

Product name

Your product's name.

slot
{product}
from
make it yours: your product
fallback
required
Your product

What it does

A verb phrase that finishes "it...".

slot
{job}
from
make it yours: what it does
fallback
required
Campaign

The offer

The value line of the campaign's offer.

slot
{offer}
from
the campaign card
fallback
required
Campaign

Tracked link

A short link of your own, so a click tells you which message earned it.

slot
{tracked link}
from
your link shortener
fallback
no link; never an untracked one
Their post

Their words

A short quote of what they posted, to show you read it.

slot
{their words}
from
the post itself
fallback
paraphrase, never invent
Their post

What happened

The trigger in plain words: launched, complained, asked.

slot
{trigger}
from
the post itself
fallback
required for cold steps
Their post

How long ago

"yesterday", "this morning". Used rarely, and only when fresh.

slot
{signal age}
from
the post's date
fallback
omit
Their post

Their current tool

The competitor they named.

slot
{competitor}
from
the post, or your own comparison notes
fallback
omit the line
The person

First name

Only when it is public and clearly theirs.

slot
{first name}
from
their public profile
fallback
no greeting name
The person

Their product

For founder leads: what they built.

slot
{their product}
from
their site or profile
fallback
omit
The person

Their site

Their domain, for the write-up offer.

slot
{their site}
from
their public profile
fallback
ask for it instead
Your product

One line of proof

A real result, quote or number with a source.

slot
{proof}
from
your own results, with a source you can show
fallback
omit; never invent proof

test one thing at a time

AxisExample variantsMeasured by
OpenerExample variantsproof first, question first, claim firstMeasured byreply rate
LengthExample variants2 lines, 5 linesMeasured byreply rate
ProofExample variantswith one sourced result, withoutMeasured byreply and click rate
Call to actionExample variantslink in the message, "want it?" firstMeasured byclick and join rate
PersonalizationExample variantstheir words quoted, not quotedMeasured byreply rate; watch for "creepy" replies
Send timeExample variantswithin 2 hours of the post, next morningMeasured byreply rate by post age

Change one axis per variant. Change the opener and the length together and the result cannot say which mattered.

What goes wrongHow it shows upHow to catch it
Placeholder leakHow it shows upA message goes out with {first name} in itHow to catch itSearch the draft for a brace before you send
Voice driftHow it shows upDrafts stop sounding like you; you edit more and moreHow to catch itNote how much you rewrite each week; roll back the prompt or template when it jumps
Creepy personalizationHow it shows up"How do you know that?" repliesHow to catch itQuote only what they posted publicly in this thread
Confounded variantsHow it shows upTwo axes changed, result unreadableHow to catch itA variant changes exactly one axis

Contact rules.

The contact policy sits above every sequence. A sequence asks for a step; the rules decide whether it may go out. Fifteen rules, as a checklist: tick the ones your plan already keeps, and close the gaps before you send anything.

8 · the limits

your plan against the rules

0 of 15 kept

Tick each rule your plan already keeps. Be honest: an unticked box is a message you have not written yet.

Person rules
Volume rules
Platform rules
Time rules

what each rule does when it fires

ActionMeans
blockMeansthe message never goes out
delayMeansthe message waits for the window or tomorrow's cap
require youMeansthe message can only be sent by you, by hand
exitMeansthe sequence ends for this person
never-contactMeansthe person goes on your never-contact list

what goes wrong with contact rules

What goes wrongHow it shows upHow to catch it
Silent skipsHow it shows upMessages vanish and nobody knows whyHow to catch itNote every message you hold back, with the rule
Cap overflow orderHow it shows upTomorrow's capped messages go out staleHow to catch itKeep the order, and re-read each one before sending
Unknown timezoneHow it shows upMessages land at nightHow to catch itFall back to your own timezone and a narrow window
Stop not carried overHow it shows upThey said stop on Reddit, got an emailHow to catch itStop is about the person: write it on the never list and check it on every channel

Their rules override yours: if a community bans links or self-promotion, that beats any sequence here. And "we chose not to send" is worth a line in your notes too.

want this run for you? vibedraft finds the people ready to buy on X and in your own signups, drafts the right move in your voice, keeps your channels posting and learns what pays. you approve everything that goes out.

Start here

Runs in your browser. Nothing you type here is sent anywhere.