Topic

How do I know if my idea is any good before I build it?

Updated

Markdown copy
Share this list on X

The short answer

Playbooks

TiboValidationBlog post

Time-box each idea to 2 weeks and kill it on any of four failing signals

After two weeks ask: are people signing up without chasing, coming back on their own, paying without heavy convincing, and giving feedback? Yes to all four: continue. No to any: kill it unless the fix is obvious.

When it applies: early validation of each new product

Rob HallamValidationNewsletter

Announce a decision publicly as a reply in a thread where people already care

Post that you're going to do something even if you haven't started or don't know how; it creates accountability and the reaction is a cheap validation test. With no audience, post it as a reply in an existing thread on the topic instead of on your own timeline.

When it applies: Zero or small audience; idea stage

Marc LouValidationPodcast

Use each launch as your marketing and your validation test

Instead of ongoing marketing he launches and watches how people react; a product with strong launch feedback and traction gets his full attention, while one that makes a couple of hundred dollars with no excitement just keeps running.

When it applies: portfolio of small products

TiboBuildingBlog post

Don't call it a product until 5-10 free early users use it twice

Build one core workflow (no dashboard, settings or polish) in weeks 1-2, give interested people free access in weeks 3-4 asking them to break it, then fix and ignore off-core requests in weeks 5-8. If they don't return a second time, keep iterating; target 5-20 paying users.

When it applies: months 1-2, post-validation

Rob HallamValidationNewsletter

Post a short no-link teaser of your idea before you build it

He posted a 27-word tease with no link and no product, then followed with a 'domain available' post, an 'I did it' post and the launch. His argument: a finished post gives people something to judge, an unfinished one gives them something to do (reply, guess, follow along).

When it applies: Pre-build or early projects; works best if you can ship quickly after the tease

Founders who talk about it