# How do I know if my idea is any good before I build it?

## The short answer

- Tibo: Post the raw idea on X/LinkedIn with no landing page; kill it under 10 unprompted inbound
- Marc Lou: Double down on a product once strangers start emailing you questions about it
- Rob Hallam: Announce a decision publicly as a reply in a thread where people already care

## Playbooks

### [Post the raw idea on X/LinkedIn with no landing page; kill it under 10 unprompted inbound](https://vibedraft.app/builder-brains/tibo/post-the-raw-idea-on-x)

Tibo · Validation · Blog post

Days 1-3: post the concept as a raw idea with no landing page or waitlist. Days 4-7: track which posts get engagement, who says they need it, and who DMs asking when it launches. If fewer than 10 people reach out unprompted, drop it.

**When it applies:** week 1, founder with some social presence

Source: [If I had to start over…](https://www.tmaker.io/blog/if-i-had-to-start-over), 26 March 2026 on tmaker.io

### [Ship one landing page a week, tweet it, and only build what gets traction](https://vibedraft.app/builder-brains/tibo/ship-one-landing-page-a-week)

Tibo · Validation · Podcast

Put up a landing page per idea, tweet about it, measure the response; no traction means next idea, traction means build it and onboard the sign-ups.

**When it applies:** pre-PMF, have an X presence

Source: [How This Solo AI Founder Bootstrapped 5 Products to 1M+ / Month | Tibo Louis-Lucas](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0UnZnonMN9o), 26 April 2026 on youtube.com

### [Time-box each idea to 2 weeks and kill it on any of four failing signals](https://vibedraft.app/builder-brains/tibo/time-box-each-idea-to-2-weeks)

Tibo · Validation · Blog post

After two weeks ask: are people signing up without chasing, coming back on their own, paying without heavy convincing, and giving feedback? Yes to all four: continue. No to any: kill it unless the fix is obvious.

**When it applies:** early validation of each new product

Source: [How to find a $1M SaaS idea](https://www.tmaker.io/blog/how-to-find-a-1m-saas-idea), 18 June 2026 on tmaker.io

### [Treat customers paying for a second month as the strongest early signal](https://vibedraft.app/builder-brains/tibo/treat-customers-paying-for-a-second)

Tibo · Validation · Podcast

Launch-month payments can be curiosity; a meaningful share paying again after month one shows real retention-backed demand.

**When it applies:** subscription SaaS, first months

Source: [The SaaS Distribution Channel Bet Behind a $12M Portfolio](https://saasclub.io/podcast/saas-distribution-channel-tibo-louis-lucas-tmaker/) on saasclub.io

### [Stop promoting for a while and see whether signups keep coming](https://vibedraft.app/builder-brains/tibo/stop-promoting-for-a-while)

Tibo · Validation · Podcast

He weighs signups that arrive while he is not tweeting or posting on Reddit far above launch spikes; organic inflow without promotion indicates real pull.

**When it applies:** after launch

Source: [The SaaS Distribution Channel Bet Behind a $12M Portfolio](https://saasclub.io/podcast/saas-distribution-channel-tibo-louis-lucas-tmaker/) on saasclub.io

### [Validate with a one-field 'Request Access' landing page before building anything](https://vibedraft.app/builder-brains/tibo/validate-with-a-one-field-request)

Tibo · Validation · Blog post

Spin up a landing page with V0 or Lovable containing a single email input and a 'Request Access' button, share it via DMs, tweets and Reddit, and count emails. No emails means skip to the next idea.

**When it applies:** pre-build, any product

Source: [7 steps to building a business](https://www.tmaker.io/blog/7-steps-to-building-a-business), 5 March 2025 on tmaker.io

### [Spot outlier products that draw more attention than your baseline and go all in](https://vibedraft.app/builder-brains/tibo/spot-outlier-products-that-draw-more-attention)

Tibo · Validation · Podcast

Tweet ideas, build MVPs, put them in real hands, and compare attention across them; the one that clearly beats your usual baseline (people chasing you in DMs) gets the focus.

**When it applies:** running many small bets

Source: [The SaaS Distribution Channel Bet Behind a $12M Portfolio](https://saasclub.io/podcast/saas-distribution-channel-tibo-louis-lucas-tmaker/) on saasclub.io

### [Double down on a product once strangers start emailing you questions about it](https://vibedraft.app/builder-brains/marc-lou/double-down-on-a-product-once)

Marc Lou · Validation · Podcast

He treats unsolicited questions and emails from users as evidence of a real need and only then spends more build time on that product.

**When it applies:** after launch

Source: [The Bootstrapped Founder #300: Marc Louvion - Becoming a Product Launch Beast](https://tbf.fm/episodes/300-marc-louvion-becoming-a-product-launch-beast/transcript), 6 March 2024 on tbf.fm

### [Announce a decision publicly as a reply in a thread where people already care](https://vibedraft.app/builder-brains/rob-hallam/announce-a-decision-publicly)

Rob Hallam · Validation · Newsletter

Post that you're going to do something even if you haven't started or don't know how; it creates accountability and the reaction is a cheap validation test. With no audience, post it as a reply in an existing thread on the topic instead of on your own timeline.

**When it applies:** Zero or small audience; idea stage

Source: [I got 334,923 views before I built anything](https://robhallam.beehiiv.com/p/i-got-334923-views-before-i-built-anything), 1 September 2026 on robhallam.beehiiv.com

### [Don't mistake likes on an idea tweet for validation; ship it with a buy button](https://vibedraft.app/builder-brains/rob-hallam/dont-mistake-likes-on-an-idea)

Rob Hallam · Validation · Podcast

He tweeted 'who would like this' for a directory of indie hackers, read 50 likes as validation, spent four months building it, and never monetized it. Put payment in from day one.

**When it applies:** idea stage, small audience

Source: [He Made $0 for a Year. Now His SaaS Makes $20K+/Month](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yvnfaAwRzgI), 20 August 2026 on youtube.com

### [Use each launch as your marketing and your validation test](https://vibedraft.app/builder-brains/marc-lou/use-each-launch-as-your-marketing)

Marc Lou · Validation · Podcast

Instead of ongoing marketing he launches and watches how people react; a product with strong launch feedback and traction gets his full attention, while one that makes a couple of hundred dollars with no excitement just keeps running.

**When it applies:** portfolio of small products

Source: [The Bootstrapped Founder #300: Marc Louvion - Becoming a Product Launch Beast](https://tbf.fm/episodes/300-marc-louvion-becoming-a-product-launch-beast/transcript), 6 March 2024 on tbf.fm

### [Don't call it a product until 5-10 free early users use it twice](https://vibedraft.app/builder-brains/tibo/dont-call-it-a-product)

Tibo · Building · Blog post

Build one core workflow (no dashboard, settings or polish) in weeks 1-2, give interested people free access in weeks 3-4 asking them to break it, then fix and ignore off-core requests in weeks 5-8. If they don't return a second time, keep iterating; target 5-20 paying users.

**When it applies:** months 1-2, post-validation

Source: [If I had to start over…](https://www.tmaker.io/blog/if-i-had-to-start-over), 26 March 2026 on tmaker.io

### [Validate an idea only by shipping it with a buy button](https://vibedraft.app/builder-brains/marc-lou/validate-an-idea-only-by-shipping)

Marc Lou · Validation · Video

Put a working product with a checkout live and see if people pay; he says AI makes shipping fast enough that this is even more true now.

Source: [How I Work: $77K/Month Solopreneur](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D4fkiQfzw_I), 26 April 2026 on youtube.com

### [Count only payment as validation, not waitlists, likes or compliments](https://vibedraft.app/builder-brains/rob-hallam/count-only-payment-as-validation)

Rob Hallam · Validation · Newsletter

He argues that asking if someone likes an idea is pointless unless you ask if they'll pay; waitlist signups and liked tweets don't count. Learned after five products that earned nothing.

**When it applies:** Idea and pre-build stage

Source: [I built 5 products that made $0](https://robhallam.beehiiv.com/p/i-built-5-products-that-made-0-dollars), 30 June 2026 on robhallam.beehiiv.com

### [Post a short no-link teaser of your idea before you build it](https://vibedraft.app/builder-brains/rob-hallam/post-a-short-no-link-teaser)

Rob Hallam · Validation · Newsletter

He posted a 27-word tease with no link and no product, then followed with a 'domain available' post, an 'I did it' post and the launch. His argument: a finished post gives people something to judge, an unfinished one gives them something to do (reply, guess, follow along).

**When it applies:** Pre-build or early projects; works best if you can ship quickly after the tease

Source: [I got 334,923 views before I built anything](https://robhallam.beehiiv.com/p/i-got-334923-views-before-i-built-anything), 1 September 2026 on robhallam.beehiiv.com

### [Live-stream your build on YouTube every morning as pre-launch validation](https://vibedraft.app/builder-brains/marc-lou/live-stream-your-build-on-youtube)

Marc Lou · Validation · Podcast

He streams 2-8 hours of coding each morning; viewers debug his code, suggest headlines and request features, giving feedback before launch and keeping him shipping.

**When it applies:** solo dev comfortable on camera

Source: [The Bootstrapped Founder #300: Marc Louvion - Becoming a Product Launch Beast](https://tbf.fm/episodes/300-marc-louvion-becoming-a-product-launch-beast/transcript), 6 March 2024 on tbf.fm

### [Ship one new product per week until one starts generating revenue](https://vibedraft.app/builder-brains/tibo/ship-one-new-product-per-week)

Tibo · Validation · Podcast

Pick a niche and positioning, recycle code, databases and components across products, and launch weekly; judge each by paid revenue, not downloads or active users.

**When it applies:** pre-PMF founders with reusable stack

Source: [The SaaS Distribution Channel Bet Behind a $12M Portfolio](https://saasclub.io/podcast/saas-distribution-channel-tibo-louis-lucas-tmaker/) on saasclub.io

### [Sell the outcome as a manual service first, then convert clients into first users](https://vibedraft.app/builder-brains/rob-hallam/sell-the-outcome-as-a-manual)

Rob Hallam · Validation · Newsletter

Romàn ran an agency selling lead packages manually before writing software; it validated demand, funded him, and those same clients became Gojiberry's first users at launch.

**When it applies:** B2B ideas where the outcome can be delivered by hand

Source: [I built 5 products that made $0](https://robhallam.beehiiv.com/p/i-built-5-products-that-made-0-dollars), 30 June 2026 on robhallam.beehiiv.com

### [Cap any new product at one month, then leave weak ones running and move on](https://vibedraft.app/builder-brains/marc-lou/cap-any-new-product-at-one-month)

Marc Lou · Validation · Podcast

He never spends more than about a month on an unproven product; if the launch brings a little revenue but no excitement he keeps it live (no shutdown) but stops investing time.

**When it applies:** early-stage, multiple bets

Source: [The Bootstrapped Founder #300: Marc Louvion - Becoming a Product Launch Beast](https://tbf.fm/episodes/300-marc-louvion-becoming-a-product-launch-beast/transcript), 6 March 2024 on tbf.fm

## Founders who talk about it

- [Tibo](https://vibedraft.app/builder-brains/tibo)
- [Marc Lou](https://vibedraft.app/builder-brains/marc-lou)
- [Rob Hallam](https://vibedraft.app/builder-brains/rob-hallam)

## Related topics

- [Is it OK to copy a product that already works?](https://vibedraft.app/builder-brains/topics/copy-proven)
- [How do I find a startup idea worth building?](https://vibedraft.app/builder-brains/topics/finding-ideas)
- [Is my market big enough?](https://vibedraft.app/builder-brains/topics/market-sizing)
- [How do I pick a niche?](https://vibedraft.app/builder-brains/topics/niche-selection)
- [How do I find ideas in complaints and bad reviews?](https://vibedraft.app/builder-brains/topics/pain-mining)
- [Can I sell it before I build it?](https://vibedraft.app/builder-brains/topics/pre-selling)

Updated 2026-11-07. [Web version](https://vibedraft.app/builder-brains/topics/idea-validation)

Advice cards are rewritten summaries with a link to the original. They are not the founder's words unless shown in quotation marks.
