# Is it OK to copy a product that already works?

## The short answer

- Rob Hallam: Build features that copy a concept that went viral 2-3 months ago
- Marc Lou: Don't clone a proven idea; twist it until it is novel
- Tibo: Win a crowded category by solving the job behind the feature

## Playbooks

### [Build features that copy a concept that went viral 2-3 months ago](https://vibedraft.app/builder-brains/rob-hallam/build-features-that-copy-a-concept)

Rob Hallam · Marketing · Podcast

Scan top posts daily for concepts that already went viral (e.g. a tweet 'algorithm simulator'), note ones you could build into your product, then ship and demo your version once a couple of months have passed so audiences have forgotten.

**When it applies:** product with a visual/demoable feature, audience on X

Source: [I Quit My Job, Flew to Brazil, and Built a $14k/Month SaaS](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F6yp_7a_R7w), 11 January 2026 on youtube.com

### [Copy a product already making money and make one part much better](https://vibedraft.app/builder-brains/rob-hallam/copy-a-product-already-making-money)

Rob Hallam · Ideas · Newsletter

Pick a category with proven revenue, copy the core, and pick one dimension to be clearly better at (Postiz added AI-agent support to a commodity scheduler). He chose X growth tools because Tweet Hunter had shown demand. Once demand is proven, the remaining risk is execution, which you control.

**When it applies:** Choosing what to build

Source: [I built 5 products that made $0](https://robhallam.beehiiv.com/p/i-built-5-products-that-made-0-dollars), 30 June 2026 on robhallam.beehiiv.com

### [Don't clone a proven idea; twist it until it is novel](https://vibedraft.app/builder-brains/marc-lou/dont-clone-a-proven-idea)

Marc Lou · Ideas · Newsletter

Being the 10th-100th AI profile picture generator or scheduler gets ignored by both algorithms and people. Take what worked and make it weird or different so it has novelty.

**When it applies:** Choosing what to build next

Source: [Why nobody is following you (yet)](https://newsletter.marclou.com/p/why-nobody-is-following-you-yet), 5 July 2025 on newsletter.marclou.com

### [Win a crowded category by solving the job behind the feature](https://vibedraft.app/builder-brains/tibo/win-a-crowded-category-by-solving)

Tibo · Building · Interview

Competitors built Twitter schedulers; Tweet Hunter helped people write better content (a feed of viral tweets to adapt), which differentiated it.

**When it applies:** crowded tool categories

Source: [Here's how Tibo sold two products for $8M, and why he'll never do it again](https://www.indiehackers.com/post/iwykhfENoZqJgRLU33zv) on indiehackers.com

### [Build for the itch your own marketing creates, in a category with paying competitors](https://vibedraft.app/builder-brains/rob-hallam/build-for-the-itch-your-own)

Rob Hallam · Ideas · Podcast

He used AI to help analyze and craft tweets for his agency's X marketing, noticed tools like Tweet Hunter hadn't integrated AI, and built that, treating existing paid competitors as validation.

**When it applies:** idea stage

Source: [He Made $0 for a Year. Now His SaaS Makes $20K+/Month](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yvnfaAwRzgI), 20 August 2026 on youtube.com

### [Don't dismiss a 'saturated' space; flip an existing model to the other side](https://vibedraft.app/builder-brains/tibo/dont-dismiss-a-saturated-space)

Tibo · Ideas · Podcast

He thought creator-brand matching was saturated back in 2015, then noticed a newer player (Passionfruit) doing well with ready-to-book sponsorship packages for creators; he suggests flipping it into a sponsorship page for brands.

**When it applies:** idea stage

Source: [Creator tools you can build that will print money](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o_gPsFb17T4), 7 August 2024 on youtube.com

### [Replace a tool you already pay for with a version niched to your case](https://vibedraft.app/builder-brains/tibo/replace-a-tool-you-already-pay)

Tibo · Ideas · Podcast

Go through your own subscriptions, pick one, and build a narrower version that fits your specific situation; others likely share your odd use case.

**When it applies:** idea stage

Source: [How This Solo AI Founder Bootstrapped 5 Products to 1M+ / Month | Tibo Louis-Lucas](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0UnZnonMN9o), 26 April 2026 on youtube.com

## Founders who talk about it

- [Tibo](https://vibedraft.app/builder-brains/tibo)
- [Marc Lou](https://vibedraft.app/builder-brains/marc-lou)
- [Rob Hallam](https://vibedraft.app/builder-brains/rob-hallam)

## Related topics

- [How do I find a startup idea worth building?](https://vibedraft.app/builder-brains/topics/finding-ideas)
- [How do I know if my idea is any good before I build it?](https://vibedraft.app/builder-brains/topics/idea-validation)
- [Is my market big enough?](https://vibedraft.app/builder-brains/topics/market-sizing)
- [How do I pick a niche?](https://vibedraft.app/builder-brains/topics/niche-selection)
- [How do I find ideas in complaints and bad reviews?](https://vibedraft.app/builder-brains/topics/pain-mining)
- [Can I sell it before I build it?](https://vibedraft.app/builder-brains/topics/pre-selling)

Updated 2026-11-07. [Web version](https://vibedraft.app/builder-brains/topics/copy-proven)

Advice cards are rewritten summaries with a link to the original. They are not the founder's words unless shown in quotation marks.
